It’s been a while since I last addressed the matter of Star Wars on DVD — specifically, George Lucas’ stubborn and frustrating determination that the general public will never again see the pre-1997, unrevised (which, by the way, is quite a different animal from unrestored) editions of the classic original trilogy in any kind of high-quality video format.
For those of you who may have only recently joined us, let me state for the record that I am not one of these “George Lucas raped my childhood” types. I didn’t think the prequels were all that bad, Jar-Jar Binks is not the end of western civilization, and I don’t even begrudge George becoming very, very wealthy by exploiting the devotion of his fans. After all, nobody held a blaster to our heads and forced us to buy yet another box set of the same damn movies we already own five copies of, and it’s not like Lucasfilm is the only company guilty of practicing the “double-dip” marketing strategy. Hell, I don’t even particularly mind that he chose to use our beloved franchise as a test platform for his ideas about digital filmmaking — which I suspect was his true (and probably only) interest in revisiting Star Wars all along — and I also forgive him the sin of not being the man he was 35 years ago. People age, and their thinking about a lot of things changes along the way, and sometimes their skills decline, too. That’s life.
But the one thing I can’t forgive is The Great Flanneled One’s zeal to suppress the earlier, more significant editions of three of the most important movies of the last 50 years.* It wasn’t the Special Editions that changed everything for Hollywood, and I don’t understand George’s lack of respect for film history, if not for his own fans (I’m the first to admit that hard-core fans can sometimes be pretty damn annoying). Even so, his position on Star Wars is downright hypocritical given his support for film preservation in general; he’s been quoted as saying that he’s concerned about saving the films he watched when he was young. Just not the films people of my generation watched when we were young, apparently.
But don’t take my rant for it. Consider this lengthy but well-reasoned op-ed that outlines the history of the situation and makes a passionate argument on behalf of both old-school fanboys and general cinephiles (I count myself as both, incidentally). The following point, in particular, is the thing I wish we could somehow get through George’s thick skull:
Continue Reading…