I imagine “daunting” must be a completely inadequate word for what actors experience when they take on roles that were made iconic by larger-than-life personalities like Jack Nicholson and Louise Fletcher. However, the cast of a local production of One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, currently showing at the Midvale Main Street Theater, show little sign of having a legendary Hollywood classic looming over them as they run through the story of a stubbornly individualistic man struggling against the petty institutional authority that wants to control him.
The Girlfriend and I were in the front row tonight to support our friend Geoff Richards, who has the part of Cheswick, one of the mental patients whose outlook is changed by the arrival of a rabble-rouser named McMurphy. Playing McMurphy, lead actor Garrick Dean does occasionally channel Nicholson’s distinctive delivery, but honestly, I don’t see how anyone couldn’t in this particular role, and he never allows himself to fully lapse into a distracting impersonation. Lead actress Eve Speer is hissibly evil as Nurse Ratched, one of the all-time great villains of screen and literature, while Rog Benally, a citizen of the Navajo Nation, is heart-breakingly effective as Chief Bromden. There were a few opening-night bumps — the gentleman playing Dr. Spivey seemed to be having trouble recalling his lines and some recorded audio in one scene was a little too quiet and possibly mis-timed — but overall, this was a thoroughly entertaining evening with a story that means a lot to me personally, and which I’ve not revisited in far too long. As Anne said, it’s a surprising mixture of grim and uplifting. Hey, that’s how they did it in the ’70s, babe!
Oh, as for the most important thing, Geoff did a fine job — he’s really improving with each new role, and I’m not just saying that. If I can say this without sounding too awkwardly sentimental, it’s been exciting to watch his progress over the past couple of years as he’s gone from a total neophyte just beginning to investigate a new interest to a seasoned thespian with several plays under his belt.
Cuckoo’s Nest has a fairly short run, only five more nights — tomorrow and Saturday, and then the 18th, 19th, and 20th next weekend — so if any of my local readers are interested at all, I advise them not to hesitate. You can order tickets online and save a couple bucks, or get them at the door. The venue is the former Comedy Circuit on Midvale’s historic Main Street, if that helps at all. Man, I could tell a few stories about that place as well as its eccentric owner Spin, who just happens to be my neighbor these days…