My Take on the Port Controversy

As much as I hate to admit it, I think President Bush made a good point yesterday when he suggested that there’s something wrong with opposing an Arab-owned company operating U.S. shipping ports when a British-owned company has been doing the job for years. He’s right, there is a double standard at play in this debate, and it is tinged with an uncomfortable hint of racism, or at least of playing favorites with our allies and business partners.

But the president, in his usual zeal to support corporations and big business deals above any other concern, misses the very important question at the heart of this matter. It isn’t, “Why is it okay for a European company to operate our ports but not a Middle Eastern one?” The actual question is (or ought to be), “Why in the hell are we allowing any foreign company to operate our ports?”

Now, I don’t believe that I’m especially xenophobic or isolationist, but, at risk of sounding like one of them totalitarian, anti-capitalist types, I do believe that certain industries and activities are so intimately connected to our national security that we should restrict them to home-grown companies only, if not outright nationalize them. Transportation is the obvious (and pertinent) example. Communication is probably another. How is it that a president who has built his entire reputation on the rubric keeping the nation safe from outside danger doesn’t seem to see this?

(I’ll give you a hint: the answer is in the second paragraph…)

spacer

2 comments on “My Take on the Port Controversy

  1. anne

    I think that part of the issue here is that no one was really aware that the ports were being controlled by any foreign company, British or other. And there is still the issue of the UAE being involved with the terrorists of 9/11. But as you said, “The actual question is (or ought to be), “Why in the hell are we allowing any foreign company to operate our ports?”

  2. jason

    Yeah… from what I’ve been reading, the actual work at the ports is still by unionized American workers. The foreign companies just run the administrative end and sign the checks. Theoretically, it’ll be no more easy or difficult for the bad guys to do their dirty work now than before. But still, this situation makes me feel itchy…